Stock Trends Gauge of Investor Sentiment: A Market at the Crossroads of Renewal

  • 07 October 2025 |
  • Written by  Skot Kortje, Stock Trends Analyst
  • font size
  • Print

The Stock Trends Gauge of Investor Sentiment has long served as a vital compass for interpreting the emotional currents that drive markets. By measuring the distribution of Bullish and Bearish Stock Trends indicators across all New York Stock Exchange issues, this gauge transforms the abstract notion of “market mood” into a quantifiable, observable pattern of investor behavior. Over the past two decades, it has proven to be an uncanny mirror of investor psychology — revealing when fear gives way to opportunity, and when euphoria conceals risk.

A Two-Decade Reflection of Market Psychology

The most recent 20-year sweep of this indicator offers a remarkable chronicle of market history. From the depths of the 2008–2009 financial crisis to the speculative heights of 2021 and the recovery now emerging in 2025, the alternating dominance of red (Bearish) and green (Bullish) areas on the Stock Trends chart maps a psychological landscape every bit as important as the economic one. The NYSE Bulls vs. Bears 20-year graph reveals the aggregate trend insight below.

BullsvsBears 20years

When nearly all stocks across the NYSE sank into Bearish or Weak Bearish classifications during the 2008 collapse, the indicator reached an extreme rarely seen — a visual manifestation of panic and capitulation. That red tide subsided through 2009 as investor confidence cautiously returned, marking the inception of a decade-long bull market. The story repeated itself in miniature through the Eurozone crisis of 2011, the oil crash of 2016, and again during the pandemic shock of 2020. Each surge of red in the gauge coincided with despair, and each contraction of red — the gradual reappearance of green — signaled the birth of a new advance.

In contrast, the years of exuberant green tell their own cautionary tales. Periods when Bullish sentiment exceeded 80 percent of all NYSE stocks — such as 2014 and 2021 — corresponded closely with overextended optimism and subsequent market peaks. In those phases, investors had largely exhausted the supply of new buyers; there was little room for breadth to expand further. History’s verdict is clear: when nearly everyone is Bullish, the potential for disappointment grows.

PeriodSentiment ReadingMarket EventSentiment ImplicationMarket Outcome
Late 2007 – Early 2009 Bearish > 85%, Bullish < 10% Global Financial Crisis bottoming Panic and capitulation; nearly all NYSE stocks bearish Major bottom (March 2009); start of decade-long bull market
2010 – 2011 Bullish rising > 70% →  sharp reversal 2011 Eurozone & U.S. debt crisis Sentiment collapsed amid global fears Short-lived bear market; recovery began late 2011
2013 – Mid 2014 Bullish > 80%, Weak Bearish minimal S&P benchmark 1,550 → 2,000 Mature phase of 2010s bull; market paused in 2015  
2015 – Early 2016 Bearish ~75–80% China devaluation & oil crash Sentiment pessimistic, breadth collapse Bottom Feb 2016 → renewed bull trend
2018 Q4 Bearish surge > 70% Fed tightening & trade war sell-off Fear spike, sentiment washed-out Sharp bottom Dec 2018; new rally through 2019
Early 2020 Near 100% Bearish COVID crash Maximum fear and liquidation Fastest reversal in history → massive bull 2020-21
Late 2021 Bullish ~90%, Weak Bearish minimal Post-pandemic euphoria Euphoria phase – excess liquidity and breadth saturation Preceded 2022 bear market
2022 – 2023 Bearish ~80%, Bullish < 20% Inflation & rate shock Broad pessimism and valuation compression Bottom Oct 2022 → 2023 recovery
Mid 2024 – 2025 Bullish recovering to ~60–65% Early-cycle upswing Gradual re-accumulation; cautious optimism Suggests new bull phase with room to expand

The Gauge as a Contrarian Indicator

Stock Trends’ framework of trend analysis is grounded in the principle that the market’s aggregate state reflects both price and psychology. The Gauge of Investor Sentiment embodies that philosophy. It serves not as a momentum indicator, but as a contrarian signal of cyclical extremes — the moments when collective perception diverges most from underlying value.

When Bearish classifications dominate more than 80 percent of issues, the crowd has already acted on its pessimism. At such extremes, the odds favor contrarian accumulation, not liquidation. Conversely, when Bullish indicators encompass a similar majority, the market often enters a stage of complacent overconfidence. In both cases, the turning point is less about valuation than emotion — the pendulum of sentiment swinging beyond reason.

This pattern has persisted with remarkable consistency. In 2009, 2016, 2020, and 2022, the Stock Trends Gauge of Investor Sentiment turned from deep Bearish saturation to gradual green expansion — each time preceding a powerful market recovery. Likewise, the euphoric dominance of green in late 2021 foreshadowed the sharp reversion of 2022’s inflation-induced correction.

2025: Recovery in Progress

Today, the Gauge reveals a market in mid-transition — neither euphoric nor fearful, but cautiously constructive. The proportion of Bullish and Weak Bullish trends has expanded from the 2022–2023 Bearish lows, yet remains below the levels that historically accompany market tops. This balance reflects a market still rebuilding conviction, digesting the policy shocks and valuation resets of recent years.

In behavioral terms, it is the phase of disbelief — when investors remain hesitant to trust the rally, even as underlying participation broadens. Historically, this has been the most fertile stage of a new bull cycle. As breadth improves and new leadership emerges across sectors, the foundation for a sustainable advance is laid not in optimism, but in skepticism.

Lessons in Market Sentiment

The enduring message of the Stock Trends Gauge is that markets are not governed solely by earnings, interest rates, or policy decisions. They are shaped by the aggregate emotional responses to those forces — fear, greed, confidence, doubt — reflected daily in the trends of thousands of individual securities.

By quantifying those responses, the Gauge gives investors a crucial edge. It teaches that bottoms are born in pessimism, not clarity, and that tops are crowned by comfort, not caution. For long-term investors guided by Stock Trends methodology, this insight remains essential: sentiment extremes are not the enemy — they are opportunity’s advance warning.


How Investors Can Use the Gauge

  • Track extremes, not headlines. Bearish shares above ~80% historically align with durable lows within weeks to months.
  • Fade euphoria. Bullish shares sustained above ~80% warn of late-cycle risk and thinner upside.
  • Respect breadth transitions. Crossovers and persistent expansions in green indicate improving participation and healthier uptrends.
  • Weak Bullish and Weak Bearish surges.  A spike in the percentage of Weak Bullish stocks warns of a market top. A rise in the percentage of Weak Bearish stocks alerts of a market bottom.

Markets turn when sentiment exhausts, not when the news flow turns rosy. The Stock Trends Gauge gives investors a disciplined lens on that process — a breadth-based translation of crowd emotion into objective signals. In 2025, it argues for measured optimism: the crowd isn’t convinced yet, and that is often where opportunity begins.

Conclusion

The market of 2025 stands at a delicate but promising juncture. The scars of the 2022–2023 downturn have yet to fully fade, but beneath the surface, strength is building. The Stock Trends Gauge of Investor Sentiment — that quiet barometer of collective mood — suggests that this is not the time to look backward in fear, but forward with disciplined optimism.

For those who understand that markets turn not when the news improves, but when sentiment exhausts its pessimism, the signal is clear: the crowd is still uncertain, and that, as always, is where opportunity begins.


Methodology: The Gauge aggregates weekly Stock Trends classifications (Bullish, Weak Bullish, Weak Bearish, Bearish) across NYSE constituents (stocks only, not ETFs). Proportions are computed as a share of the investable universe each week, forming a market-wide breadth profile of trend states. For individual issues, consult the Stock Trends Strategy Summaries (NYSE) and security-level Stock Trends Reports. The Nasdaq, NYSE American, and TSX Summaries are also featured weekly.

back to top

Subscriber Testimonials

  • Thank you for your excellent work and kind approach to your customers.

    Odette C., Subscriber

  • I've followed your recommendations since reading your columns in the Globe & Mail, and finding they published Stock Trends arrows in their financial listings. I do find them a guide to the general market and what I should be avoiding for declining chart trends.
    Has probably saved me the subscription by not rushing into hot stocks!

    Anthony D., Subscriber
  • Stock Trends analysis quantifies nicely the movement of individual stocks. I’ve found that if the technicals are out of synch with fundamental analysis, it is a wake-up call to make a decision. The Stock Trends Bull/Bear Ratio is useful in identifying major market bottoms and tops. It has always presented a good buying or selling opportunity.

    Charles G., Subscriber
  • I find your website and research very helpful in my stock trading. I have subscribed to several related services in the past and none present their work with “just the facts” as you. Please keep up the great work so that I can continue to learn! 

    Bryan E., Subscriber
  • Stock Trends information is part of the base information I review before making a trade.

    Subscriber
  • An admitted cynic, it's obviously very high praise when he says he likes StockTrends because of its "simplicity, utility, openness, [and] honesty," and in addition to having "no hidden agenda" is "understandably documented [and] historically verifiable." And, he adds, "It lets me see a lot of things without doing a lot of work." Globe and Mail

    Paul W., Subscriber

  • Stock Trends Weekly Reporter is an easy way to pick up equities that represent an upward trend.

    Subscriber
  • I want to thank you for posting such an excellent guide to technical analysis on the web. You have provided a great service to all of us novice investors.

    Michael C., Stock Trends user
  • You have created and maintained an amazing, highly educational program and I am grateful for your part in getting our retirement funds to the good place they are.

    Karin M., Subscriber
  • I've followed a number of Stock Trends picks, and the methodology is solid.

    Doug B., Subscriber

  • I am just writing to tell you of my appreciation of your service! It makes so much sense to me. You seem to be an oasis of stability and sensibility in a stockmarket jungle.

    Adrian S., Subscriber

  • Your report is an impressive, excellent tool and I have recommmended it to friends.

    Colin E., Subscriber

  • Hence, anyone who had followed the "Stock Trends" line should have sold their Bre-X shares and, with the windfall, paid for a lifetime subscription to The Globe and Mail and more. Talk about return on investment!

    Muni P., Subscriber

  • Just thought I'd call to thank you, Skot. Stock Trends Weekly Reporter helped pay for my daughter's education!

    Peter H., Subscriber

  • I am something of a momentum investor. I find Stock Trends useful as I can look at my portfolio as a “watch list” and quickly see where trends are declining in strength or reversing, so it is particularly useful as a tool in portfolio management regarding sales.

    William C., Subscriber
  • I use Stock Trends to help direct my stock picks. Also, following the advice of Stock Trends I have religiously used stop-loss orders and have avoided hanging on to losing stocks for emotional reasons.

    John B., Subscriber
  • I have had the good fortune to be reasonably successful and enjoy the investment process. Your process would be recommended for both experts and those who are new to investing.

    Frank I., Subscriber
  • There is a lot to be gained from comparing trends of how individual stocks are doing within a sector, as well as how the sector is performing relative to the broad market.

    Dudley R., Subscriber

  • I am fascinated with your service and methodology - it is very impressive. [...] Over the years I have concluded that there are many ways to approach stock investing, but once one has chosen a path, one is better off sticking to it.

    Bob E., Subscriber

  • I very much like the systematic approach to analyzing stock data, it fits my approach.

    Subscriber

Subscription Plans

Subscription Plans

STWR - Monthly

$19.95

Monthly subscription plan to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter - pay your monthly subscription fees by having them automatically charged (PayPal only). Free 7-day trial period. Subscribers may cancel before the end of any subscription month.

STWR - 1 Year Prepaid Subscription

$199.00

1 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 16% off monthly rate!

STWR - 2 Year Prepaid Subscription

$299.00

2 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 37% off monthly rate!

STWR - 3 Year Prepaid Subscription

$399.00

3 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 44% off monthly rate!

Stock Trends Editorial

  • Positioning for Opportunity: Trade Detente and Stock Trends Momentum
    Positioning for Opportunity: Trade Detente and Stock Trends Momentum The easing of tensions between the world’s two largest economies has given markets a fresh narrative. By stepping back from new export restrictions and cutting key tariffs, the United States and China have removed some of the most disruptive threats hanging over global supply chains. For investors, this détente creates a backdrop of relative stability in which powerful price trends can resume and new trend…
    Read more...
  • From Flash Crash to Rotation: The Probability–Payoff Map of a Rebuilding Market
    From Flash Crash to Rotation: The Probability–Payoff Map of a Rebuilding Market The market’s October tremor—an abrupt but short-lived flash crash—has given way to a familiar pattern in the Stock Trends framework: the rapid repair of breadth and the birth of new trends. Where panic once pressed prices indiscriminately, order is returning through a disciplined sequence of new bullish signals, rebuilding sectors, and the subtle reorganization of leadership beneath the surface.
    Read more...
  • Random Portfolios as a Benchmark: A Smarter Yardstick for Performance
    Random Portfolios as a Benchmark: A Smarter Yardstick for Performance Investors often compare performance to market indexes like the S&P 500, but traditional benchmarks have built-in biases. The S&P 500, for example, is heavily skewed toward large-cap stocks and “is not a good benchmark for measuring alpha” – it reflects a size-factor bias rather than pure manager skill. All major indexes systematically tilt toward certain factors (size, sector, value/growth, etc.), meaning they’re not truly passive…
    Read more...
  • Using the Stock Trends Reports in Market Corrections
    Using the Stock Trends Reports in Market Corrections Sharp market selloffs are stressful… and useful. They create a live-fire laboratory where leadership quality is revealed in real time. In the Stock Trends framework, the most informative sequence is a stock that registers a New Weak Bullish () during the shock — a pullback statement in a bullish primary trend — and then, within a week, flips back to a Return to Strong Bullish (). That…
    Read more...
View all Stock Trends Editorials
 
 

Subscription Plans

STWR - Monthly

$19.95/Month

Monthly subscription plan to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter - pay your monthly subscription fees by having them automatically charged (PayPal only). Free 7-day trial period. Subscribers may cancel before the end of any subscription month.

STWR - 1 Year Prepaid Subscription

$199/Year

1 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 16% off monthly rate!

STWR - 2 Year Prepaid Subscription

$299/2 Years

2 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 37% off monthly rate!

STWR - 3 Year Prepaid Subscription

$399/3 Years

3 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 44% off monthly rate!