Bullish Crossovers - an event worth watching

  • 24 March 2012 |
  • Written by  Skot Kortje, Stock Trends Analyst
  • font size
  • Print

The Bullish Crossover () indicator provides evidence of positive expectations as a trade entry signal. This article has a look at some of the statistical returns generated after a Bullish Crossover.

Technical analysis is rooted in the premise that stock prices ‘trend’ and those patterns of price trends repeat themselves. This assumption is, in some circles, supported by empirical evidence. In other circles, though, it is equally refuted by empirical evidence. Some market analysts don’t subscribe to the notion that price movements are predictable. In fact, they espouse theories focused on the randomness of price movement. These theories, like the Random Walk Hypothesis, are a hopeless framework for taming the markets and achieving superior relative returns. Stock Trends, however, adheres to the religion found in the churches of market technicians – the belief that patterns repeat themselves. The code is written; it only needs to be cracked.


If stocks do trend, what evidence can we provide? Stock Trends is an event driven analysis. It categorizes stocks as either Bullish or Bearish, with six different trend indicators that define every equity issue traded on the NYSE, NASDAQ, NYSE-Amex, and TSX. Each indicator is also coupled with a specific Relative Strength Indicator, a measurement of relative price momentum over a 13-week period. In conjunction with our trend counters we can group specific events – matching trend indicators, Relative Strengths indicators, and time measurements (how many weeks has the trend indicator been in effect).


For instance, if a stock has changed to Weak Bearish () and is outperforming the market by at least 10 per cent (RSI is 110 or greater), what is the historical subsequent price performance for all stocks that matched this criteria? We can further limit the grouping to include stocks at the same share price level or similar in terms of trading volume. With over 7.4-million weekly records in our database these statistical summaries are of interest, to be sure. Indeed, the results of those surveys direct our development of trading systems based on the Stock Trends indicators.


The primary event that the Stock Trends service focuses on is the Bullish Crossover (). This event marks the crossover of the secondary trend line above the primary trend line, as defined by our simple 13-week moving average and 40-week moving average trend lines. For many market timing investors this event seems far too lagging, and would not appeal to their timing sensibilities. However, the following survey of our weekly data provides supporting statistics for the Bullish Crossover signal, especially when used in conjunction with the Relative Strength Indicator.


Our weekly records go back to 1980 for U.S. stocks, 1993 for Canadian stocks. We tend to limit our evaluation of the Stock Trends indicators to issues trading above $2 since penny stocks prove to be extremely volatile. For purposes of this survey, only common stocks and income trust units are included, since exchange traded funds are typically based on baskets of instruments.


Given the limits defined above, our data shows us over 63,000 Bullish Crossovers. How significant are these events? A measurement of the change in share price in the period after the moving average crossover tells us whether an investor can count on positive expectations for a favourable trade.


Of the 63,395 events, the majority of stocks (within one standard deviation of their mean returns over the following measurement periods) with Bullish Crossovers had returns ranging as below after the subsequent 13- and 40-week periods:


13-weeks - (-22%) to +28%
40-weeks - (-46%) to +62%


Further, 27 per cent of stocks had gains of 10% and above after 13-weeks, while 14 percent had gains of at least 20%. At the 40-week mark, 39% of stocks had a 10%-plus gain and a 28% had a gain of at least 20%. However, these results are for all Bullish Crossovers in the subset regardless of their concurrent price momentum. What happens when we limit the set of observations to those stocks that were outperforming the market significantly at the time of its Bullish Crossover?


For stocks that were outperforming the market by at least 20% (as an example) - an RSI of 120 or higher – the number of Bullish Crossovers in our weekly data history totals 19,367. Of that subset, the range of returns for the majority of stocks is as follows:


13-weeks - (-31%) to +39%
40-weeks - (-68%) to +92%


Of the Bullish Crossovers with an RSI above 120, 42 per cent had at least a 10% gain 40-weeks later; 34 per cent had at least a 20% gain.


One thing we can learn from these statistics is that price momentum at the time of a Bullish Crossover improves the probability that a stock will generate positive returns. It is one of the reasons Stock Trends focuses on stocks with strong relative price performance. Indeed, investors using our service should always be looking at the Bullish trend events - the Bullish Crossover and Weak Bearish indicators – with respect to the Relative Strength Indicator (RSI).


The positive expectations of these statistics for the subsets described are evidence of broader market forces at work. Every stock, though, represents an individual market. And each stock will have its own specific behaviours that might not correlate to the broader market price movements. It is important to measure the historical performance of an individual stock and compare it to the performance of the broader market.


For instance, Citigroup (NYSE:C) is a recent Bullish Crossover, as are many U.S. financial stocks. How does its historical performance compare to that described above? Does it show a tendency to move in a similar pattern?


If we look at the history of Citigroup's stock after it has had a Stock Trends Bullish Crossover (22 times), its range of 40-week performance is (-31%) to +70% - with a 46% probability of at least a 10 per cent return, and a 41% probability of at least a 20 per cent return. Citigroup’s stock had an RSI of 122 at its Bullish Crossover two weeks ago, so its comparative set measurements can be found if we limit our data survey to Bullish Crossovers stocks with an RSI ranging between 120 and 125. The probability of at least a 10 per cent return 40 weeks after the Bullish Crossover for that set of stocks (numbering 5,230) is 41%, so the expectations for Citigroup’s stock are in line with that of the statistical grouping it currently fits.


Of course, past performance is not a guarantee of future performance, and certainly the market conditions are always distinct. It is hard to know if the discounts written in past price performance fully represent the risks of current or future market conditions. But that is the nature of technical analysis. Investors who espouse its practices – long-term conservative investors as much as trigger-happy technical traders – must model their own trading plans around the probabilities that any particular trade will succeed in providing the returns necessary given the risks involved. Stock Trends hopes to help you achieve good results by highlighting stocks with positive expectations over the intermediate and long-term time horizon.

 

back to top

Subscriber Testimonials

  • There is a lot to be gained from comparing trends of how individual stocks are doing within a sector, as well as how the sector is performing relative to the broad market.

    Dudley R., Subscriber

  • Stock Trends information is part of the base information I review before making a trade.

    Subscriber
  • I am something of a momentum investor. I find Stock Trends useful as I can look at my portfolio as a “watch list” and quickly see where trends are declining in strength or reversing, so it is particularly useful as a tool in portfolio management regarding sales.

    William C., Subscriber
  • Your report is an impressive, excellent tool and I have recommmended it to friends.

    Colin E., Subscriber

  • I have had the good fortune to be reasonably successful and enjoy the investment process. Your process would be recommended for both experts and those who are new to investing.

    Frank I., Subscriber
  • I've followed your recommendations since reading your columns in the Globe & Mail, and finding they published Stock Trends arrows in their financial listings. I do find them a guide to the general market and what I should be avoiding for declining chart trends.
    Has probably saved me the subscription by not rushing into hot stocks!

    Anthony D., Subscriber
  • You have created and maintained an amazing, highly educational program and I am grateful for your part in getting our retirement funds to the good place they are.

    Karin M., Subscriber
  • I use Stock Trends to help direct my stock picks. Also, following the advice of Stock Trends I have religiously used stop-loss orders and have avoided hanging on to losing stocks for emotional reasons.

    John B., Subscriber
  • Thank you for your excellent work and kind approach to your customers.

    Odette C., Subscriber

  • Stock Trends analysis quantifies nicely the movement of individual stocks. I’ve found that if the technicals are out of synch with fundamental analysis, it is a wake-up call to make a decision. The Stock Trends Bull/Bear Ratio is useful in identifying major market bottoms and tops. It has always presented a good buying or selling opportunity.

    Charles G., Subscriber
  • I very much like the systematic approach to analyzing stock data, it fits my approach.

    Subscriber
  • Stock Trends Weekly Reporter is an easy way to pick up equities that represent an upward trend.

    Subscriber
  • Hence, anyone who had followed the "Stock Trends" line should have sold their Bre-X shares and, with the windfall, paid for a lifetime subscription to The Globe and Mail and more. Talk about return on investment!

    Muni P., Subscriber

  • An admitted cynic, it's obviously very high praise when he says he likes StockTrends because of its "simplicity, utility, openness, [and] honesty," and in addition to having "no hidden agenda" is "understandably documented [and] historically verifiable." And, he adds, "It lets me see a lot of things without doing a lot of work." Globe and Mail

    Paul W., Subscriber

  • I am fascinated with your service and methodology - it is very impressive. [...] Over the years I have concluded that there are many ways to approach stock investing, but once one has chosen a path, one is better off sticking to it.

    Bob E., Subscriber

  • I've followed a number of Stock Trends picks, and the methodology is solid.

    Doug B., Subscriber

  • I am just writing to tell you of my appreciation of your service! It makes so much sense to me. You seem to be an oasis of stability and sensibility in a stockmarket jungle.

    Adrian S., Subscriber

  • I want to thank you for posting such an excellent guide to technical analysis on the web. You have provided a great service to all of us novice investors.

    Michael C., Stock Trends user
  • Just thought I'd call to thank you, Skot. Stock Trends Weekly Reporter helped pay for my daughter's education!

    Peter H., Subscriber

  • I find your website and research very helpful in my stock trading. I have subscribed to several related services in the past and none present their work with “just the facts” as you. Please keep up the great work so that I can continue to learn! 

    Bryan E., Subscriber

Subscription Plans

Subscription Plans

STWR - Monthly

$19.95

Monthly subscription plan to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter - pay your monthly subscription fees by having them automatically charged (PayPal only). Free 7-day trial period. Subscribers may cancel before the end of any subscription month.

STWR - 1 Year Prepaid Subscription

$199.00

1 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 16% off monthly rate!

STWR - 2 Year Prepaid Subscription

$299.00

2 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 37% off monthly rate!

STWR - 3 Year Prepaid Subscription

$399.00

3 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 44% off monthly rate!

Stock Trends Editorial

  • Stock Trends Inference Model: A Statistical Foundation for Smarter Investing
    Stock Trends Inference Model: A Statistical Foundation for Smarter Investing At the heart of Stock Trends is a conviction: market data is not noise, but information. For more than three decades, the Stock Trends framework has given investors a disciplined way to interpret market cycles, trend signals, and momentum patterns. The Stock Trends Inference Model (ST-IM) is the natural extension of this approach, embedding rigorous statistical reasoning into the reports available for every listed stock…
    Read more...
  • Technology Sector Split: Hardware & Chips vs. Software – A Deep Dive with Stock Trends
    Technology Sector Split: Hardware & Chips vs. Software – A Deep Dive with Stock Trends The uncertain interest rate environment is evident in a number of sectors, and the stock market is always reflecting both the trend of the cost of capital and the anticipation of changes in it. The technology sector is especially sensitive to interest rates and generally feeds off the risk-on investor appetite supported by lower interest rates or expectations of relatively lower rates. But all technology…
    Read more...
  • Resource rotation remains strong
    Resource rotation remains strong The summer season is coming to a close. It is sometimes a sleepy market season because investor attention is elsewhere. However, the market has provided us with some definite messaging over the past few months. The themes of rotation and building strength in resources and energy stocks, notably fueled by an AI transformation across the broader economy, are key highlights that investors should pay attention…
    Read more...
View all Stock Trends Editorials
 
 

Subscription Plans

STWR - Monthly

$19.95/Month

Monthly subscription plan to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter - pay your monthly subscription fees by having them automatically charged (PayPal only). Free 7-day trial period. Subscribers may cancel before the end of any subscription month.

STWR - 1 Year Prepaid Subscription

$199/Year

1 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 16% off monthly rate!

STWR - 2 Year Prepaid Subscription

$299/2 Years

2 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 37% off monthly rate!

STWR - 3 Year Prepaid Subscription

$399/3 Years

3 Year Prepaid subscription to Stock Trends Weekly Reporter. Save 44% off monthly rate!